"I am also a Libby’s gal. Part of that is nostalgia. It’s the brand I grew up using. Part is due to the quality, reliability and consistency of their pumpkin puree," says Tricia Stuedeman.

The challenge in attempting to compensate for the moisture in pumpkin puree is that it varies. The standard can of Libby's pure pumpkin puree is relatively dense and creamy, but some brands are ...